Colour or Black and White?

I often ask this question. I began my photographic journey using B&W medium format film back in 1968. I don’t think it is nostalgia, but I do have a preponderance to preferring monochromatic images. Colour is very important in my life but it is always a toss up between deciding to make B&W images or colour. Of course, it is very much simpler when using my medium format or large format equipment because the decision has been made by what I have loaded into the magazines or dark slides. In that case I go out with the intention of making either colour or B&W. In a recent review of Jane Bown’s career she said that ‘colour got in the way’. I can see that for portrait work, however does the same apply to abstract images, or more correctly abstraction?

When it comes to digital, I reckon I can shoot an image with B&W in mind. One such image was made on Boxing Day. This morning, having wussed out of either a walk or a bicycle ride I set about manipulating this image as both as the eye saw it and how the mind’s eye saw it.

As the eye saw it
As the eye saw it
As the mind's eye saw it
As the mind’s eye saw it

The colour version, in my mind is colder than the B&W.

Thoughts?

1 thought on “Colour or Black and White?”

  1. I agree Tom, obviously due to the pale blue wash. The white splogh of paint is also not as distracting in the B&W image.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *